Waterproof vs Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes: Which Pair Will Keep You Trekking Comfortably?

How often have you stood before a wall of shoes, wondering whether to choose waterproof or non-waterproof hiking shoes for your outdoor adventure?

The choice isn’t always straightforward. Different trails and personal preferences mean that what works for one hiker may not work for another.

Let’s look at the real pros and cons of both options.

Waterproof vs Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes – Main Differences

Waterproof vs Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes – What They Are & How They Work

There is no single right answer. The choice between waterproof and breathable hiking shoes depends on where you hike, the climate, terrain, and your preferences.

How Waterproof Hiking Shoes Work

Waterproof hiking shoes keep you dry and warm by using proprietary membranes—thin, fabric layers integrated between the inner lining and outer material.

These filters have microscopic pores that block water while venting sweat and heat. All brands use similar technology. There's a trade-off, though.

Compared to non-waterproof shoes, impermeable models may trap heat and sweat. Choose based on your hiking needs.

How Breathable Hiking Shoes Work

By comparison, non-waterproof footwear offers greater comfort and improved ventilation in warm conditions. They’re ideal for fast-paced hiking since they allow sweat to evaporate and are lighter.

Waterproof Hiking Shoes Pros and Cons

If what you’re looking for are shoes that keep your feet dry and warm, then waterproof footwear should be your go-to choice.

Waterproof Hiking Shoes Pros

• Comfort and dryness– they’re excellent at helping you avoid wetness when you’re hiking through shallow water streams, during rainy days, or in the winter.
• Warmth– they’re made with a special membrane that offers boosted insulation and protects your feet from the cold.
• Stain resistance – these shoes are durable and resist dirt. They’re also easier to clean, most of the time.
• Debris protection – reduces the risk of fine slit, sand, and dirt from getting inside the shoes.

Waterproof Hiking Shoes Cons

• Reduced breathability – being water-resistant also makes them retain heat and sweat, which can become a bit uncomfortable.
• Heavier weight – some waterproof hiking shoes can be stiffer and heavier than the more breathable alternatives.
• Slow drying time – if somehow water gets inside the shoe from the top part, your feet might stay wet for a longer period, since the breathability is pretty low.
• Shorter lifespan – waterproof membranes deteriorate over time.
• Higher price tags – waterproof footwear is generally more expensive than its non-waterproof counterparts.

Pros and Cons of Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes

Breathable hiking shoes are ideal for warmer weather and dry conditions, made from flexible, lightweight materials that dry quickly.

Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes Pros

• Increased breathability –your feet will remain cool and sweat-free because moisture escapes easily from these shoes.
• Flexible and lightweight – they have higher flexibility and are lighter on your feet, which can reduce fatigue during long hikes.
• Fast-drying – most of these shoes are made of breathable mesh, which dries quicker than waterproof models after rain or when submerged.
• More affordable– not having the special waterproof membrane makes these shoes less expensive. They’re also easier and quicker to manufacture.

Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes Cons

• Unsuitable for cold and wet hiking conditions– your feet won’t remain warm during winter days because there’s little to no insulation with mesh-made hiking shoes.
• The lack of protection from water– they don’t offer any moisture protection, so expect your feet to get soaked if you step into puddles or even wet grass. 
• Less durable fabrics– this footwear could break down more quickly than waterproof (sturdier) shoes because of its thin materials.

Best Hiking Shoes for Wet Trails

Your go-to pick should be a product that offers enough support and cushioning for wet, more difficult hiking trails, keeping you dry while still allowing you to move freely and easily. Here are our top choices.

1. DualStride Armadillo FieldLite Waterproof 

• Boosted comfort and great stability.
• Incredible shock absorption.
• Solid toe protection and increased durability.
• Waterproof protection
• Lugged rubber for a firm grip.

2. Women's Lightweight Water-Resistant Hiking Shoes

• Excellent EVA insole for boosted comfort.
• Durable and lightweight.
• Increased support and stability.
• Superior traction.
• Water and debris resistant.

3. Men's Waterproof Hiking Boots

• Amazing traction and enhanced comfort.
• Outstanding durability and quite breathable for a waterproof shoe.
• Protective rubber toe cap design.
• Flexible and removable foam insole offers arch support.

Waterproof vs Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes – FAQs

Do I Need Waterproof Hiking Shoes?

You only need this type of footwear when you go hiking on rainy, cold days, in winter, or in muddy conditions. They’re essential for snowy mountain exploration, rainy autumn days, and winter off-road routes.

When Should I Choose Waterproof Hiking Shoes?

You should opt for waterproof hiking shoes when you’re about to go on muddy trails, wet terrains, and through shallow waters. These are also great for winter hiking and damp conditions.

When Should I Opt for Non-Waterproof Hiking Shoes?

You should wear breathable shoes when hiking in dry, hot weather. Summer trails and deep river crossings are also situations in which you should choose non-waterproof hiking accessories, because they dry off quickly and let sweat out.

Are There Hybrid Hiking Shoes or Alternatives?

Yes, you could use waterproof socks under your breathable shoes, or apply DWR spray to them, to create a water-impermeable barrier.

Final Thoughts

Choosing between these two types of hiking shoes boils down to a few factors: hiking conditions, terrain, and personal preferences. If you’re climbing or walking on wet grass, through mud, or in heavy rainfall, you should definitely opt for waterproof models.

However, dry, hot climates usually require more breathable, lightweight alternatives to boost comfort. There’s no universally ideal choice here, only the option that suits your hiking style best.